Workpuls Teramind ActivTrak Hubstaff DeskTime Time Doctor RescueTime Kickidler Veriato Work Examiner
OVERVIEW
Price $6/user/month $6/user/month $7.20/user/month $7/user/month $7/user/month $9.99/user/month $6/user/month $9.99/user/month $150/licence/year $60/licence (lifetime)
Free trial 7 days 7 days No 14 days 14 days 14 days 30 days 7 days Yes 30 days
Ease of use Very easy Difficult Very easy Easy Easy Very easy Very easy Very easy Very difficult Easy
TRACKING METHODS
Unlimited (tracker working 24/7)
Fixed (defined working hours)
Automatic (when computer is connected to a specified network)
Manual (start/stop)
Project based (track time only on projects)
GENERAL MONITORING FEATURES
Stealth mode
App and website usage
Real-time monitoring
Offline time tracking
Attendance
Activity levels
Keylogger
Geolocation
Remote desktop control
Website/activity blocking
SCREENSHOTS AND RECORDING
Screenshots
Screenshots on demand
Screen recording
PRODUCTIVITY FEATURES
Productivity trends
Websites and apps labeling
Category labeling
Productivity alerts
ADVANCED SECURITY FEATURES
User behavior analytics
Data loss prevention
Advanced file and web monitoring
REPORTING
Productivity reports
Team reports
Timelines
Email reports
Access management
PLATFORMS
Web
Mac desktop app
Windows desktop app
Linux desktop app
Mobile app iOS, Android iOS, Android iOS, Android iOS, Android iOS, Android Android
Browser extension Chrome Chrome Chrome
Other Citrix, VMware Chrome OS
OTHER
Support Phone, email, online Phone, email, online Phone, email, online Email, online Phone, email, online, in-person Online Phone, email, online Email, online, Viber, Whatsapp Phone, email, online, support ticket Phone, email, online
Knowledge base
Video tutorials
Integrations comming soon
API
Deployment cloud, on-premise cloud, on-premise, AWS, Azure cloud cloud cloud cloud cloud on-premise cloud, on-premise on-premise
Kronos Humanity Timeclockplus Tsheets Wheniwork Deputy Replicon Jibble EbilityTimeTracker OnTheClock BeeBole
OVERVIEW
Price(per month)Available upon requestFrom $2 per userAvailable upon requestFrom $6.40 per user+$16Free for up to 75 usersFrom $2.50 per userBasic plan:$30 for 5 users+$5 per additional userFrom $1.50 per employeeFrom $4 per user+$8From $2.20 per user$5.99 per user per month
Free trial30 days14 daysYes14 days14 days14 days30 days30 days,no credit card required
Ease of useDifficultEasyDifficultVery easyEasyEasyDifficultVery easyEasyEasyEasy
FEATURES
Timecard management
Scheduling
Shift Trading
Timesheets
Break time management
Real-time tracking
PTO Management
Payroll
Invoicing
Client billing
GPS tracking
Clock out reminders
Alerts
Manual time
PUNCH-IN METHODS
Web app
Mobile app
Time clock device
Time clock kiosk
Facial recognition
Fingerprint scanning
Geofencing
Group punch-in
REPORTING
Visual reports
Email reports
Time rounding
MANAGEMENT
Permissions
Manager approvals
Add time for others
Integrations
PLATFORMS
Web
Android app
iOS app
Mac desktop app
Windows desktop app
Linux desktop app
OTHER
SupportPhone and onlinePhone and onlinePhone,chat and onlinePhone and chatEmail and onlineChat and phonePhone,email,chat and onlinePhone and onlinePhone,email,chat and onlinePhone and onlineOnline chat and video support in English,French,and Spanish
Knowledge base
Video tutorials
Community forum
API
Workpuls Hubstaff Toggl TimeDoctor Harvest TimeCamp Timely Everhour Tick TMetric
OVERVIEW
Price (per month) $6 per user $5.83 per user $9 per user $9.99 per user $10.80 per user $5.25 per user $99 for 5 users $7 per user $19 for 10 projects $5 per user
Free trial 7 days 14 days 30 days 14 days 30 days Yes 14 days 14 days 30 days 30 days
Ease of use Very easy Difficult Difficult Very easy Easy Very easy Easy Difficult Very easy Difficult
TIME TRACKING METHODS
Manual
Start/stop buttons
Automatic time mapping
IN-DEPTH TASK AND PROJECT ANALYSIS
Screenshots
App and website usage
Activity levels coming soon
Real-time tracking
TASK AND PROJECT MANAGEMENT
Project adding
Project templates
Project status
Task assignment
Task priorities
Budgeting coming soon
Mark billable/non-billable hours
Payroll calculation
Invoicing
ALERTS
Idle time reminders
Deadline alerts coming soon
Budget alerts coming soon
REPORTING
Client login
Productivity analysis
Email reports coming soon
PLATFORMS
Web
Mac desktop app
Windows desktop app
Linux desktop app coming soon
iOS app Beta
Android app
Browser extension Chrome Chrome, Firefox Chrome Chrome Chrome, Firefox Chrome Chrome, Firefox, Opera, Edge
OTHER
Support Phone and online Email and online Email and online Online Online, email and phone Email, online and support ticket Email and chat Email and chat Email Chat
Knowledge base
Video tutorials
Integrations coming soon
API
On-premise hosting

Summary

The ongoing discussion about hybrid work vs remote work setups reflects the evolution of today's workplaces. Professionals now have a middle ground between the flexibility of remote roles, complete with their remote office equipment, and the collaborative spirit of traditional offices. But what is hybrid remote job productivity compared to the productivity levels of in-office employees? 

Read time: 6 minutes

Table of Contents:

  • Working from Home: A Digital Revolution
  • The Classic Office: Centralized Collaboration 
  • The Hybrid Model: The Confluence of Flexibility & Structure
  • Choosing the Right Model for Your Organization 
  • How Insightful Can Enhance Productivity Across Work Models

The workplace has undeniably transformed. 

Following the global health crisis in 2020, an estimated 88% of organizations worldwide made it mandatory or encouraged their employees to work from home. This shift brought to the forefront the necessity and challenges of diverse work models.

The decision of where employees work — be it from home, within the confines of an office, or a hybrid combination — has profound effects on productivity and overall job satisfaction. Various elements, including personal choices, opportunities for team interactions, and even daily commutes, have an influence. 

This in-depth guide delves into the unique characteristics of each model, offering insights that help businesses make informed decisions tailored to their teams. In addition, discover how employee productivity tracking tools like Insightful can ensure a productive workforce no matter their location.

Working from Home: A Digital Revolution

The seismic shift to remote work emerged as both a formidable challenge and a golden opportunity for organizations and employees alike. The benefits were palpable: A newfound flexibility allowed many to craft schedules that seamlessly integrated with personal commitments, like childcare, acting as a lifeline for numerous professionals. 

Additionally, the elimination of daily commutes has ushered in a windfall of saved time. Studies have indicated that employees, on average, reclaimed a staggering 8.5 hours each week, hours which were previously frittered away in transit. 

The autonomy to craft a personalized workspace has also proven beneficial. A significant segment of the workforce discovered that by customizing their work environment, they could elevate their productivity levels, with some reports suggesting a 15% uptick in self-assessed efficiency.

However, this evolution isn’t without its pitfalls. The solitude of remote work casts a shadow over its many merits. In fact, data sourced from a Buffer survey revealed a concerning trend: about 20% of remote professionals grapple with feelings of isolation and encounter communication hurdles. 

Furthermore, not all are equipped with the luxury of a dedicated workspace at home. A mere 23% of remote workers had spaces expressly designed for work, rendering them vulnerable to incessant distractions. This environment also ushered in another pressing concern. 

A study orchestrated by Microsoft spotlighted that remote employees, especially in regions like Italy and Japan, displayed a propensity to extend their working hours, inadvertently inching towards burnout.

Productivity takeaway: While remote work offers increased flexibility, time savings from eliminating commutes, and the potential for enhanced efficiency through personalized workspaces, it also brings challenges like feelings of isolation, distractions due to non-dedicated workspaces, and the risk of extended working hours that could lead to burnout.

Strategies for Productive Remote Work

  • Flexible Scheduling: Allow employees to tailor work hours around personal needs, boosting attentiveness and work quality.

  • Enhanced Communication: Invest in robust communication tools and set regular check-ins to combat feelings of isolation and maintain team unity.

  • Workspace Support: Offer subsidies for employees to create dedicated home offices, minimizing distractions.

  • Work-Life Balance: Advocate for clear 'office hours' in a home setting to prevent burnout.

  • Training & Resources: Provide concise resources on remote work best practices, such as time management and team-building exercises.

  • Feedback Mechanisms: Set up channels for employees to share their experiences and suggestions about remote work.

  • Monitor Workloads: Utilize management tools to ensure tasks are balanced and prevent overburdening.

  • Cultural Considerations: Adapt remote work policies based on regional and cultural nuances.

The Classic Office: Centralized Collaboration

The conventional office environment continues to offer a suite of unique benefits. A research piece from Harvard underscores the psychological shift that occurs when employees physically travel to a workspace: merely entering the office often acts as a catalyst, activating a distinct 'work mode' mindset. 

Furthermore, the power of in-person collaboration cannot be understated. A striking 75% of employees, when surveyed, expressed a belief that their creativity and innovation thrived in the office setting, primarily owing to face-to-face interactions. 

And, of course, the practical advantages of office spaces play a pivotal role. Employees have streamlined access to an array of resources, including advanced hardware, bespoke software, and essential amenities that may not be readily accessible from home.

Yet, despite its merits, the traditional office environment isn't devoid of challenges. A comprehensive study from Stanford sheds light on the detrimental effects of daily commuting. The research conclusively links prolonged commute times with heightened stress levels and diminished job satisfaction. 

Additionally, the rigidity of fixed working hours in such settings can often be counterproductive. A revealing poll by Gallup indicated that a significant 44% of employees harbor a preference for some degree of scheduling flexibility, which starkly contrasts with the structured timing of traditional offices. 

While collaboration is a boon, the office setting has its own set of distractions. From impromptu meetings to casual office conversations, such interruptions can accumulate, accounting for an alarming 21% dip in overall productivity.

Productivity takeaway: While the traditional office environment fosters a distinct 'work mode' mindset and enhances creativity through in-person interactions, it also presents challenges such as the stress of commuting, lack of scheduling flexibility, and potential distractions, which can significantly impact overall efficiency.

Strategies for Productive In-office Work

  • Dedicated Work Zones: Establish clear zones for different tasks: collaboration areas, silent workspaces, and break rooms.

  • Tech Integration: Employ staff tracking and productivity tools and software to streamline tasks and enhance inter-departmental communication.

  • Flexible Work Hours: Allow for staggered start and end times to reduce commute stress and accommodate different personal schedules.

  • Breaks and Downtime: Ensure scheduled breaks for mental refreshment and minimize the risk of burnout.

  • Distraction Minimization: Designate specific times for meetings and informal chats, reducing impromptu distractions.

  • Feedback Loops: Create systems for regular feedback from employees to continually refine and improve workspace productivity.

  • Ergonomic Spaces: Design workspaces with ergonomics in mind, ensuring comfortable and health-supportive settings for prolonged work periods.

The Hybrid Model: The Confluence of Flexibility & Structure


Emerging as a potential future for myriad organizations, the hybrid model ingeniously amalgamates the strengths of both home-based and office-centric work cultures. At the heart of this approach is unparalleled flexibility. 

Employees are empowered to judiciously select their working environment, tailoring their choices based on the nature and demands of specific tasks. This autonomy often translates to heightened efficiency and satisfaction. 

Reinforcing the importance of physical presence, a study highlighted that a robust 68% of the workforce continues to find in-person meetings more impactful and productive than their virtual counterparts. Thus, the hybrid model, while leveraging the power of digital, ensures that the essence of face-to-face networking isn't lost. 

Additionally, when it comes to striking a harmonious chord between professional commitments and personal life, the hybrid model emerges as a frontrunner. Reports and testimonials consistently resonate with the idea that this model facilitates an optimal work-life balance, serving the best of both realms.

Yet, as with any paradigm, the hybrid model presents its own set of challenges. A telling poll unveiled that approximately 32% of managerial personnel grapple with the nuances of managing hybrid teams, with coordination and oversight often becoming intricate. Moreover, an unintentional underbelly of inequality might develop in such setups. 

Employees who lean towards more frequent office attendance could inadvertently find themselves at the center of impromptu decision-making discussions or, in some cases, be perceived as more committed, potentially influencing promotional opportunities. 

Lastly, the logistics involved in flawlessly executing a hybrid model can be daunting, especially in the initial phases. Organizations often face a steep learning curve in ensuring technological robustness and seamless coordination, aspects crucial for the model's success.

Productivity takeaway: The hybrid model offers a balanced approach to work, potentially maximizing productivity by merging the flexibility of remote work with the collaborative benefits of in-person interactions.

Strategies for Productive Hybrid Work

  • Environment Selection: Allow employees to pick where they work based on the task at hand.

  • Face-to-Face Value: Schedule regular in-person meetings, leveraging their effectiveness over virtual ones.

  • Work-Life Harmony: Promote the hybrid approach as a means to balance professional tasks and personal time.

  • Managerial Training: Provide guidance for supervisors on managing diverse, spread-out teams.

  • Equal Opportunity: Ensure decision-making includes all, irrespective of their work location.

  • Tech Support: Invest in seamless technology for both in-office and remote tasks.

Choosing the Right Model for Your Organization

The nature of specific tasks plays a crucial role in this decision. 

For instance, activities such as brainstorming often flourish in face-to-face settings, while tasks like coding or writing might achieve peak efficiency when done remotely. 

One cannot underestimate the value of employee feedback in this transition. Alarmingly, in 2020, a mere 38% of companies took the initiative to survey their employees about their work location preferences, missing out on crucial insights. 

Embracing an approach of trial and error can also be enlightening. Notable organizations, including Siemens and Salesforce, have pioneered this method, instituting trial periods to assess the efficacy of varying work models. This experimental phase helps in fine-tuning strategies and aligning them more closely with both organizational goals and employee well-being.

How Insightful Can Enhance Productivity Across Work Models

Insightful is a comprehensive productivity monitoring and time tracking tool aimed at improving and tracking employee productivity across various work environments, from remote to hybrid to traditional office settings. It offers a suite of tools that allow organizations to monitor computer usage, track work hours, and even detect potential security threats.

How?

  • Staff and Time Tracking: Insightful's tracking tools offer a bird's eye view on work hours, essential for assessing workload and productivity across all models.

  • Remote Work Insights: With challenges like isolation in remote work, Insightful's real-time activity tracking offers a pulse on remote employee productivity, ensuring tasks are on track.

  • Navigating Hybrid Work: The Office vs. Remote feature provides crucial data on hybrid work performance, aiding managerial decisions.

  • Office Productivity Enhancement: Insightful’s Label Recommendation System categorizes apps and sites, pinpointing distractions in office settings.

  • Consistent Security: Insightful's Alerts secure data across work models, flagging potential insider threats, essential for the safe use of remote office equipment.

  • Seamless Integration: The platform's integration features ensure swift and secure access, vital for hybrid teams juggling between home and office environments.

Insightful acts as a bridge, helping organizations navigate the complexities of modern work models, ensuring peak productivity, no matter where their team operates.

We’ve reserved a 7-day free trial for you….

Want your hybrid or remote team to be more productive?

Claim your free 7-Day full feature trial of Insightful today. Insightful’s actionable work insights make your team more productive, efficient and accountable.

Ready to Take Full Control Of Your Workplace?

Try the simplest solution today…

Start Free Trial