How to Spot & Stop Proximity Bias in Hybrid Work

In this article, we’re going to discuss:

‍

• Why proximity bias is a hidden risk that undermines fairness in hybrid work.
• How structured policies keep promotions, recognition, and opportunities equitable.
• Why outcome-based visibility is essential for building trust across teams.
• How Insightful turns equity into a measurable, repeatable part of hybrid work.

‍

Hybrid work brings flexibility, but it also introduces new risks to fairness. One of the most damaging is proximity bias—the tendency to favor employees who are physically present over those working remotely.

It doesn’t take bad intentions for this to happen. More feedback goes to those seen in person, while hallway chats and informal decisions exclude remote colleagues. Over time, this skews promotions and recognition toward office workers, sidelining equally capable talent.

The impact is real: in 2023, remote workers were promoted 31% less often than those who spent at least some time in the office, despite comparable performance. Left unchecked, proximity bias erodes trust, drives disengagement, and stalls careers.

This guide explores how it shows up and how structured policies and tools like Insightful can help leaders detect and defeat it.
‍

How Proximity Bias Shows Up (& Why It’s Hard to Spot)

‍

One of the challenges with proximity bias is how subtle it can be. It doesn’t show up in formal policies or job descriptions but emerges in the everyday rhythms of hybrid work.

• Feedback and recognition skew in-office. Employees who are physically present tend to receive more regular input and informal praise, simply because managers interact with them more often.
  
  
• Decisions happen in the margins. Important conversations occur in hallways, lunch breaks, or after meetings—leaving remote workers excluded from key context.
  
  
• Stretch projects and promotions lean local. When leaders think of who to “tap on the shoulder” for an opportunity, those nearby are top of mind.

What makes proximity bias especially tricky is that it often goes unnoticed by managers. To them, these actions may feel natural or efficient, but for remote employees, the effects compound over time as reduced visibility, missed opportunities, and slower career progression.
‍

Why Traditional Visibility Doesn’t Work Anymore

‍

In the office, presence often stood in for performance. Leaders could see who stayed late, who spoke up in meetings, or who seemed “busy.” But in hybrid work, those signals are unreliable, and often unfair.

• Gut feel doesn’t scale. Managers relying on impressions risk overlooking remote employees who contribute just as much but aren’t physically present.
  
  
• Responsiveness ≠ productivity. Being quick on Slack or email doesn’t mean someone is producing meaningful results.
  
  
• Activity isn’t the same as impact. Time spent online or in meetings says little about progress toward outcomes.

Relying on old measures creates blind spots that reinforce proximity bias. To lead hybrid teams effectively, organizations need structured systems and objective signals—clear standards that apply equally, no matter where employees work.
‍

How to Build Inclusion into Hybrid Leadership

‍

Proximity bias can’t be solved with good intentions alone. Leaders need structured practices that make inclusion a repeatable part of how teams operate. That means designing systems where location doesn’t determine opportunity.

Here’s how to do it: 
‍

Step 1: Set Location-Neutral Performance Standards

‍

One of the simplest ways to reduce proximity bias is to make sure success is measured by what people deliver—not where they work from. Instead of vague expectations like “be available” or “be responsive,” define role-based outcomes that are specific, measurable, and tied to business results.

Examples:

• For customer support reps → Average resolution times, CSAT scores, tickets closed.
  
  
• For engineers → Features shipped, bugs resolved, sprint velocity.
  
  
• For marketing teams → Campaign launches, engagement metrics, qualified leads.
  
  

The key is to document these standards clearly so managers evaluate contributions based on outcomes, not presence. This levels the playing field between in-office and remote employees.Insightful strengthens this process by validating whether performance standards are achievable
under real working conditions. For instance, if data shows engineers are losing 40% of their week to meetings, managers can recalibrate sprint goals or remove blockers. By surfacing trends in focus time, app usage, and context switching, Insightful ensures goals aren’t just fair on paper—they’re fair in practice.
‍

Step 2: Audit Promotions & Opportunities Quarterly

‍

Proximity bias often shows up in career development. Employees who are physically present tend to get tapped for promotions, high-visibility projects, or recognition—simply because they’re top of mind. To counter this, leaders should run regular audits of advancement opportunities.

Practical ways to do this:

• Review promotion lists each quarter for balance across remote and in-office employees.
  
  
• Track stretch project assignments to ensure remote workers aren’t overlooked.
  
  
• Document recognition events (awards, shout-outs, bonuses) and check whether they’re distributed fairly.

These audits don’t just surface inequities—they also give leaders a chance to proactively rebalance opportunities before disengagement sets in.

Insightful provides a data-driven layer to these audits by showing how engagement and workload trends differ across employees. For example, if remote workers are consistently experiencing more meeting overload and less focus time than office peers, that may explain why they’re falling behind in recognition or advancement. Managers can use these insights to adjust workloads, provide support, and ensure remote employees have the same chance to shine.
‍

Step 3: Design Communication and Recognition Remote-First

‍

In hybrid environments, many career-shaping conversations still happen informally—after a meeting ends, in the hallway, or at a team lunch. Remote employees often miss these moments, which means they miss both context and recognition. To level the field, leaders should design communication and recognition practices that assume not everyone is in the room.

Practical ways to do this:

• Default to async updates (Slack, Teams, Notion) for project progress and decisions.
  
  
• Document key takeaways from meetings and share them where everyone can access.
  
  
• Make recognition visible to all—use shared channels, team emails, or all-hands shout-outs.
  
  
• Record and distribute meetings to give remote employees equal access to context.
  
  

When recognition and communication default to remote-first, inclusion isn’t dependent on being physically present.

Insightful helps measure whether these practices are actually working. If the data shows that some employees spend most of their time stuck in meetings while others have more focus time, leaders can intervene to rebalance workloads. Similarly, if remote employees show declining engagement, it may signal they’re not fully benefiting from communication or recognition systems—giving managers a chance to course-correct before bias sets in.
‍

Step 4: Train & Hold Managers Accountable for Inclusion

‍

Even with the best policies in place, proximity bias can creep back in if managers aren’t trained and held accountable. Training should go beyond awareness—it needs to give managers practical methods to lead inclusively.

Practical ways to do this:

• Include bias awareness modules in manager onboarding and leadership training.
  
  
• Provide checklists and playbooks (e.g., who to involve in decisions, how to balance stretch assignments).
  
  
• Encourage peer reviews of promotion and recognition decisions to flag inequities.
  
  
• Make inclusion part of performance expectations for managers—track it just like business goals.

This ensures inclusive leadership isn’t optional; it’s embedded in the way managers are evaluated and rewarded.

Insightful reinforces accountability by giving leaders visibility into how inclusion is being practiced day-to-day. For example, if one manager’s team consistently shows higher meeting overload or lower engagement compared to others, it’s a signal that inclusive practices aren’t being applied effectively. By surfacing these trends, Insightful helps organizations spot where additional coaching or training is needed—turning inclusion from a value into a measurable practice.
‍

The Benefits of Tackling Proximity Bias

‍

Addressing proximity bias doesn’t just create a fairer workplace—it delivers measurable business outcomes:

• Higher retention: Employees who feel recognized and included are far less likely to leave, reducing costly turnover.
  
  
• Greater engagement: Fair access to feedback, opportunities, and recognition keeps both remote and in-office employees motivated.
  
  
• Stronger performance: Clear, objective standards allow teams to focus on results instead of signaling presence.
  
  
• Inclusive talent pipelines: Promotions and stretch projects are distributed more fairly, strengthening succession planning.
  
  

A strong example comes from Stratum Benefits, a company that adopted a permanent hybrid model but struggled with visibility into workloads and recognition. By using Insightful, they gained real-time insight into both remote and in-office teams, ensuring fairness in performance evaluation and opportunity distribution. The result: improved trust, balanced workloads, and a hybrid structure that supported sustainable growth.

‍